| |
From
abortion to contraception: A resource to public policies and reproductive
behavior in Central and Eastern Europe from 1917 to the present.
Henry David
Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1999.
(hardcover, 382 pp.)
Review by S. Marie Harvey
This impressive volume provides
a comprehensive, archival, and historical record of public policy,
reproductive behavior and women's rights in Central and Eastern
Europe (CEE). The book encompasses more than seven decades of
socialist rule and nearly a decade of postsocialist transition
in 28 CEE countries. The 15 contributors examine the interaction
between public policy and private reproductive behavior and review
each country's unique experience within a broader historical,
psychosocial and public health context. A unique feature of the
volume is its women-centered approach and the placement of contraception
and abortion firmly within the context of women's rights and status.
The book is comprised of two parts:
Part I, the Introduction, consists of three chapters and Part
II includes nine Central and Eastern European country reports
presented in alphabetical order. The first chapter, an Overview
of the book by Henry David, introduces the organizational structure
of the book, discusses the content of Chapters 2 and 3, and outlines
and summarizes the major themes addressed in the nine country
chapters. In Chapter 2, 'Understanding the 'Abortion Culture'
in Central and Eastern Europe,' Libor Stloukal provides insight
into the reasons for the reliance on abortion within Central and
Eastern Europe. From 1960 to 1990 legal abortion rates in CEE
were the highest in the developed world. Explanations for the
high abortion levels during these decades included liberal abortion
laws; lingering pronatalist views; limited and erratic availability
of modern contraceptives; the use of ineffective or no methods
for avoiding unintended pregnancy; and the slow acceptance of
feminism and personal responsibility. Abortion rates have declined
and continue to decline nearly everywhere in CEE. While the trend
today is toward contraception and responsibility for individual
behavior, Stloukal concludes that 'the transition from abortion
to contraception remains an incomplete process in the CEE countries.'
In Chapter 3 Henry David and Joanna
Skilogianis review the historical development of socialist views
on what they refer to as the 'woman question.' This phrase was
introduced by a the German Social Democratic Party theoretician,
August Bebel, in the nineteenth century and was subsequently used
by others. All nine country reports include a section devoted
to a review of the country-specific trends and the impact of political
change on women's rights and status. Chapter 3 provides an overview
of the historical development of the socialist view on the woman
question before and after the October 1917 Revolution in the former
Soviet Union. The authors summarize the effects that the political
and economic transitions from socialism to more democratic political
systems are having on such issues as women's rights, reproductive
health, and feminism. For many of the CEE countries, the transition
process resulted in a decline in women's rights and gender equality.
The change from centrally planned to market economies negatively
affected women in many ways including increased unemployment,
poverty, a decrease in political representation, a lower level
of health care, and poorer living conditions. The transition marked
a return to traditional patriarchal values and to the multiple
burdens for many women as worker, mother and wife. David and Skilogianis
conclude that the women question remains unresolved in the CEE
countries.
This book has many strengths and
much to recommend it. First, the volume is comprehensive and inclusive
in its content, approach and geographic scope. The editor acknowledges
that traditional demographic studies of reproductive behavior
are too broad-based. He incorporates a microlevel approach to
facilitate a better understanding of the multifaceted determinants
of sexual and reproductive behavior. Thus, the analysis of the
determinants of fertility behavior moves beyond the pure demographic
and public policy approach to include the reproductive health
perspective. 'Private reproductive behavior involves a series
of individual decisions reflecting historical, political, economic,
social, cultural and other values and traditions.' Within this
broad interdisciplinary approach, each country report considers
a range of factors affecting sexual and reproductive behavior
including 'society values and traditions, Marxist theory, socialist
and patriarchal perceptions of gender roles, the status of women
as producers of labor and reproducers of families, changes in
legislation facilitating or constraining access to modern contraceptives,
pronatalist incentive influences on demographic trends, attitudes
of health service providers, views on sexuality education, adolescent
sexual behavior, and emerging roles of public services and nongovernmental
organizations.'
The geographic scope of book is
equally impressive covering 28 formerly socialist countries of
Central and Eastern Europe and the USSR successor states from
1917 to the present. Although each of the country chapters is
similarly organized to address common topics, the determinants
of fertility behavior varied greatly between and within countries.
Thus, the authors review each country's unique experience within
a broader context. Historical and current information specific
to each country is presented and, when available, statistical
data (e.g., birth rates, total fertility rates, legal abortion
rate, legal abortion ratios, maternal mortality rates and ratios)
displayed in easy to read tables and figures are also presented.
It is noteworthy, that this volume has compiled extensive data
and information about reproductive health issues in countries
where such information has been previously unavailable or extremely
difficult to come by.
The book is also distinguished
in terms of quality and coherence. All chapters are well written,
thoroughly researched and meticulously documented. The nearly
1300 references are combined into a single chapter with listings
by author in alphabetical order. Although this is an edited volume
with 15 contributors and is ambitious in scope, the individual
chapters refer to and are informed by one another. Because the
country chapters are organized to address common topics and because
of the skillful editing by David, the book forms a coherent whole.
Each country chapter begins with an introduction by David in which
he discusses the historical context and outlines the topics to
be addressed. A commentary on "Future Perspectives"
concludes each chapter.
Perhaps what I find most profound
and valuable about From Abortion to Contraception, is its
focus on the 'woman question.' A unique feature of the volume
is the examination of the interrelationships among public policies,
private reproductive behavior and women's roles and status. Through
his women-centered approach and the placement of contraception
and abortion firmly within the contexts of women's rights and
status, David affirms the 1994 Program of Action of the International
Conference on Population and Development (ICPD) held in Cairo.
Women's control over their own reproductive health and fertility
has been and continues to be an enduring goal of feminism. If
women are to achieve full social, political and economic equality,
they must have easy access to a continuum of pregnancy prevention
and termination options. Moreover, the most effective way to prevent
unintended pregnancy, change reproductive behavior and improve
women's health is to elevate the status of women by providing
the means for social and economic self-determination. David concludes,
however, that the extent to which access to modern contraceptives
and safe abortion is available to all women is, to a large degree,
dependent upon whether 'public policy concurs or conflicts with
private values.'
In summary, I commend David and
his colleagues for their efforts to place contraception and abortion
in the context of gender equality and women's status. Given its
breadth and depth of information and its quality and coherence,
this book is an invaluable resource not only for demographers
but also for historians, policy-makers, social scientists, public
health and women studies scholars, and health and human rights
advocates.
|